As the First World War drew to a close, a significant yet understated meeting took place between Turkish commander Khalil Pasha and two British officers: the legendary Lawrence of Arabia and liaison officer Aubrey Herbert. This encounter, steeped in the geopolitics of empire-building, was marked by a poignant exchange that underscored the deep complexities and human costs of the conflict.
The Meeting The meeting occurred during a period of reflection and reevaluation of alliances and enmities. Khalil Pasha, recognizing the shared objectives of empire-building, suggested to his British counterparts that there was no inherent reason for Britain and Turkey to be adversaries. His statement, “after all, gentlemen, our interest as Empire builders are much the same as yours. There is nothing that need stand between us,” reflected a perspective of mutual benefit and strategic alignment.
The Response Aubrey Herbert’s response, “Only a million dead Armenians,” served as a stark reminder of the atrocities committed during the war, particularly the Armenian Genocide, which claimed the lives of an estimated 1.5 million Armenians. This retort brought to the forefront the moral and ethical considerations that often become obscured in the grand narratives of empire and war.
The Suspected Voice The biography of Lawrence of Arabia by his friend Robert Graves suggests that the incisive reply attributed to Herbert might have actually originated from Lawrence himself. This speculation adds another layer to the historical account, as Lawrence was known for his deep understanding of the region and its peoples. If true, it would reflect Lawrence’s awareness of the tragic consequences of political maneuvers and the human toll of imperial ambitions.
The exchange between Khalil Pasha and the British officers encapsulates the dichotomy between the strategic interests of empires and the human tragedies that unfold in their shadows. It serves as a powerful reminder of the enduring impact of war on nations and individuals alike. The meeting, though a small episode in the larger tapestry of the war, offers a profound insight into the complexities of history and the importance of remembering those who suffered its greatest costs.
For those interested in exploring the nuances of this historical moment and the broader context of World War I, a wealth of literature, including the works of Robert Graves, provides a deeper understanding of the events and their significance.
