In late 1915 a young Jewish woman from Palestine, Sarah Aaronsohn, was travelling by train from Istanbul to Haifa to get away from her husband, and she saw the Armenian Genocide with her own eyes. Outside the carriage window, the Armenians of the Ottoman Empire were being deported and destroyed. Her account of what she saw became one more piece of testimony to the Genocide, and the sight itself changed her life: she came to run the work of the NILI spy ring in Palestine, which helped the British, and in October 1917 she shot herself in her parents’ house rather than betray her comrades.
Sarah was born on 5 January 1890 in Zikhron Ya’akov, at the foot of Mount Carmel. Her parents had come from Romania with the first wave of Zionist settlers and were among the founders of the village (Wikipedia). Her elder brother Aaron Aaronsohn, a well-known agronomist, pushed her to study. She spoke Hebrew, Yiddish, Turkish and French fluently, knew Arabic fairly well and taught herself English (Jewish Women’s Archive).
In March 1914, when Sarah was twenty-four, she was married off. The wedding took place in Atlit on 31 March: the groom, Haim Abraham, was a wealthy merchant from Bulgaria and an active Zionist. According to family accounts, her parents were pleased with the match; the bride was much less so. The couple moved to Istanbul, the capital of the empire, where Sarah found herself in a foreign city, in a foreign apartment, with a husband whom biographers describe as a difficult and jealous man (Wikipedia, Armeniapedia). The marriage did not work.
The First World War began in the summer of 1914, the Ottoman Empire joined Germany’s side, and in April 1915 the deportations of Armenians began. That autumn, while her husband was away on business, Sarah bought a ticket for the train from Istanbul to Haifa. She believed the worst thing in her life had already happened: an unhappy marriage. Historians differ on small points. Gregory Wallance, the author of her full biography, says she left in November and that her brother Aaron met her near Haifa in mid-December (The Jewish Press).
The train crossed Asia Minor, and the country outside the window was not the one travellers usually see. Wallance writes of burning villages, heaps of bodies on both sides of the tracks, and Armenian families stumbling along the roads while guards kicked, beat and shot the stragglers, and dogs fed on the corpses (Jewish Light). Later Sarah described what she had seen: hundreds of dead men, women, children and infants; sick Armenians loaded into freight cars, the dead thrown out and the living put in their place (Wikipedia, citing Bartov and Mack’s collection In God’s Name).
She spoke of it very little. After she got home she did not cry, according to those close to her. Any mention of Armenians threw her into a fit of severe hysteria, and it stayed that way for the rest of her life (Armeniapedia, Wikipedia).
From what she saw she drew a conclusion that historians would later spend volumes explaining. If the state could do this to Armenians, who had lived in Anatolia for centuries, then when their turn came it would do the same to the Jews of Palestine. Encyclopedia.com makes the same point: for her the genocide was state policy, not an outburst of cruelty. The feeling that the turn would sooner or later come to them was shared across the Aaronsohn family. Aaron feared the same thing. The news that Djemal Pasha had threatened to extend the “Armenian policy” to the Jews reached Zionist leaders through Chaim Weizmann (Armenian Weekly), and on 28 March 1917 he ordered the evacuation of the inhabitants of Jaffa and Tel Aviv (Wikipedia).
Sarah did not wait for her turn. The NILI spy ring had been founded in the spring of 1915, before her return, by her brothers Aaron and Alexander and their friend Avshalom Feinberg. The name is an acronym of “Netzach Yisrael Lo Yeshaker”, “the Eternal One of Israel will not lie” (Wikipedia: Nili). By the end of 1915 she had joined the underground (JWA) and began to direct its work on the ground in Palestine, passing information to British agents who waited offshore.
She travelled across Ottoman lands, gathering information on the troops and carrying it herself to the British in Egypt, then returning. By 1917 the ring had about forty members, and her reports, according to Wallance, helped British aviation gain superiority over Sinai (Wikipedia, Jewish Light). She was twenty-five, and twenty-seven when it all ended.
In 1917 Alexander urged his sister to stay in British-held Egypt, where it was safe. She went back to Zikhron Ya’akov to continue the work.
In September 1917 the Ottomans intercepted a NILI carrier pigeon and deciphered the code. In early October troops surrounded Zikhron Ya’akov and arrested many of its residents, Sarah among them. Her father was tortured before her eyes. She herself endured four days of beatings and interrogation, and not one name passed her lips (Wikipedia). Wallance stresses that the Turks learned nothing from her (Jewish Light).
Before she was sent to the next interrogation, Sarah asked to be allowed to go home and change her bloodstained clothes. In the bathroom, under a tile, she had a pistol hidden. According to Scott Anderson in Lawrence in Arabia, this happened on Friday, 5 October 1917. She shot herself in the mouth. The bullet destroyed her jaw and severed her spinal cord but missed the brain, and Sarah lived four more days. The physician Hillel Yaffe, according to his diary, heard her beg him to end her suffering and instead gave her morphine (Wikipedia).
She died on 9 October 1917, aged twenty-seven. In her last letter she wrote that she hoped her work would bring closer a national home for the Jews in the Land of Israel. The letter is kept in the NILI museum, in the former Aaronsohn family house in Zikhron Ya’akov (The Jewish Chronicle).
Under Jewish tradition a suicide cannot be buried in the common cemetery, but the refusal caused resentment. A compromise was found: Sarah’s grave was enclosed by a small fence, symbolically setting it apart from the consecrated ground. Pilgrimages to the grave began in 1935, and after 1967 the memory of Sarah and NILI became part of Israel’s official cult of heroism (Wikipedia).
The Turks did not kill Sarah Aaronsohn: she shot herself. But she was brought to that by two years that began with a train in December 1915.
Each scene of this story rests on different sources, and they vary in how firm they are.
| Episode | What is known | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Marriage, move to Istanbul | Wedding on 31 March 1914 in Atlit, husband Haim Abraham, an unhappy marriage | Wikipedia |
| Date of return | November or December 1915: JWA says November, Wikipedia says December, Wallance describes meeting Aaron in mid-December | JWA, Jewish Press |
| What she saw on the way | Hundreds of bodies, sick Armenians in freight cars, the dead thrown out: from Sarah’s testimony as retold by Bartov and Mack | Wikipedia |
| Pyramid of thorns, up to five thousand people | Repeated in biographies of Sarah as her testimony, but in the list of genocide testimonies on Wikipedia these words are attributed to the NILI member Eitan Belkind and placed in Mesopotamia | Jewish Press, list of testimonies |
| Founding of NILI | Founded by Aaron, Alexander and Feinberg in spring 1915; Sarah directed operations in Palestine | Wikipedia: Nili |
| Djemal Pasha’s words | The sense is confirmed by reports passed on through Weizmann; the exact phrase (“he will treat the Jews as he did the Armenians”) was not found in primary sources | Armenian Weekly |
| Arrest, four days of torture, the shot | Confirmed; sources differ on exact dates (“1 October” for the arrest) | Wikipedia, Lawrence in Arabia |
| Date of death | 9 October 1917; JWA gives 10 October | Wikipedia, JWA |
| “If I don’t go back, who will?” | Not found in the sources checked |
The overall conclusion: the core of the story is reliable. Sarah did travel along the road where the deportation of Armenians was under way, did run NILI’s work in Palestine, and did choose death rather than betray her comrades. The disputed details concern how she was talked about after her death.
No open source offers direct proof that Azerbaijani money shapes Donald Trump's policy. What exists…
Two ancient authors report that Hannibal drew up the plan of the capital of Greater…
Masis is the sacred mountain of the Armenian people. It has two names, Masis and…
Armenia has been on maps for almost three thousand years. The earliest image we know…
Historian and human rights activist Arif Yunusov lives in exile in the Netherlands. In an…
When people talk about the antiquity of Armenia, they often begin with a grand formula…